Christian Mingle vs. Christian Cafe – Comparison of the two most popular Christian dating websites

Christian Mingle Slogan: Find like-minded Christians and choose from more than 7 million members!
Christian Cafe Slogan: Are you looking for a serious relationship with a fellow Christian? Christian Cafe has got your back!

Christian MingleChristianCafe
Average rating24
Member base– 7 million active members
– 49% women – 51% men
– most members between 35-49 years old
– 1 million members
– 46% male, 54% female
– age range 25 to 54rs’ age: 35-44
Prevailing relationship format– Serious relationships
– friendships
– pen friends
– Serious relationships
– friendships
– pen friends
Mobile appyesyes
Customer supportOnsite, email
Phone hotline 1.310.893.0550
Onsite, email
Phone hotline +18774692752
What’s included in free & paid versions?Free:
– Registration
– Profile creation
– Match search
– Send smiles
– Like other profiles
– See who liked you
– See who visited your profile

Paid:
– Send and receive messages
– Hide your profile
– Notifications
– Hide online status
– Browse profiles anonymously
Free:
– Use of search filters
– Access to forums and discussions
– Post prayers on the “Prayer” page
– Add profiles to your favorites list

Paid:
– Send winks
– Send emails
– Read receipts
– Exchange information
Prices– 1 month: $49.99 / month
– 3 months: $34.99 / month
– 6 months: $24.99 / month
– 1 month – $34.97/mo
– 3 months – $16.65/mo
– 6 months – $13.33/mo
Top highlights/unique features– Excellent matchmaking system
– Browse users for free
– No fake accounts
– Ideal for those looking for serious relationships
– Ideal for single women looking for a serious relationship
– Affordable
– Excellent profile quality
– Plenty of communication features

Christian Mingle

ChristianMingle is one of the most famous religious dating websites with millions of users all over the globe. With an impressive user base and a ton of success stories, it’s a place where you can find true love based on the same religious views. If you are wondering how many users does Christian Mingle have vs. Christian Café, please read on.

Christian Café

Like ChristianMingle, Christian Café is also a dating website that promotes serious relationships and marriage, connecting people with similar religious backgrounds. It has been doing a great job since 1999 when it was first released. 

ChristianMingle vs. ChristianCafe Review

Ease of use + Design/Layout

When it comes to ease of use and design, both websites are fairly good in both categories. ChristianMingle does look a little better, with a modern design and clear, easy-to-find features that make it easy for older people to navigate. Once you create a profile for free, you can browse user profiles, view photos, and access most information without a paid subscription. The app version is not as impressive as the site, but it can help you stay in touch with your matches on the go.

ChristianCafe, on the other hand, looks good enough, and unlike ChristianMingle, it allows users to communicate with other members for free. The profiles are not very detailed, but the overall design is easy to navigate and get used to. However, the information displayed is very clear, so it’s obvious that the designers wanted to keep the entire site as uncluttered as possible. The app is not very impressive, as it features an outdated design and a confusing interface.

Winner – ChristianMingle

christian-mingle review

Sign up Process

If you’re 18, you can join ChristianMingle in a matter of minutes. It takes about 5 minutes to complete the sign-up process, and you can use the same credentials you use on other social media. Once you fill out a form with personal information, you can upload up to 6 photos to complete the registration. Lastly, you’ll have to verify your profile through email. The process is straightforward and easy to complete, but remember to answer all questions sincerely to get better matchmaking results.

Christian Café includes a free trial period once you sign up. The process takes a little longer, and the site doesn’t accept users who are already married. Once you provide your basic information, the site will give you your final username. Answer all of the questions sincerely to increase your chances of finding a date. Lastly, add a few photos, and you’re ready to start meeting single Christians in your area.

Winner – Christian Café

Profile Settings + Search Filters

ChristianMingle allows you to customize your profile to your liking. The entire process is designed to be as easy as possible to allow those who are not tech-savvy to get into dating in a few minutes. The search filters are straightforward, allowing you to look for dates based on age, looks, location, and so on. You can send messages directly to users, even with a free subscription, and you can add the users you like to your favorites list at any time.

Christian Café has more or less the same search filters and profile settings as ChristianMingle, but with a few differences. First off, the site chooses your username for you, so you can’t customize that at all. However, you can add photos, fill out boxes with more information about your interests, and use basic search filters that can be fully customized. Every user profile will give you a number telling you how much you match. The quick match feature will point you to the users you match the most with.

Winner – Christian Café

Christian Café Profile Settings

Matches Quality + Success Rate

Match quality is one of the most critical features of any dating website, and both of these are pretty good at connecting you with the perfect person. ChristianMingle doesn’t have an advanced matchmaking system based on a personality test. However, the detailed questionnaire does help you find people who share the same religious beliefs as you.  The success rate varies from one user to another, but after reading reviews on Christian Mingle vs. Christian Café for men, we can say that thousands of people found true love.

Christian Café takes a different approach to online dating. Every profile you run into will have a small number in the corner telling you how much you match with the person. That takes a lot of guesswork out of the equation and allows you to find those who share views with you quickly. It might take a little work, but it will be easy to take things further once you find a match. With over 2000 success stories on the site, we can say that it’s a great place to find love.

Winner – Christian Café 

Reliability and Safety

When it comes to online safety, both websites put a lot of effort into ensuring that their members are genuine. ChristianMingle has a strict verification system for all posts, photos, and information found on every profile, as well as an email verification process upon registration. Even though you might run into a few inactive profiles, you won’t have to worry about scammers. 

Christian Café is not as strict with its rules. You can report or block users, as you’re expected to run into a few suspicious-looking profiles. Since the site provides you with a unique username and password you can’t change, you don’t have to worry about hackers. When it comes to security in the Christian Mingle versus Christian Café standoff, it’s clear that the first-mentioned site is the winner. 

Winner – Christian Mingle

Christian Mingle Reliability and Safety

Unique Features

When it comes to unique features, reviews on Christian mingle vs. Christian Café for women are pretty divided. Some prefer the LookBook feature found on Christian Mingle, which is a standard swipe matching system. Others enjoy exchanging ideas with other members from all over the globe on Christian Café’s forums. 

Everything comes down to what you prefer. If you don’t mind getting a premium subscription on Christian Mingle, you’ll get access to unlimited messaging and a huge user base. On the other hand, if you want to meet people while exploring personal blogs and forum posts, Christian Café is the best choice. With that said, Christian Café does feel a little clunky at times, and this can ruin your entire experience.

Winner – Christian Mingle

Pricing

If you want to know how much is Christian Mingle vs. Christian Café, you came to the right place. The cost of Christian Mingle vs. Christian Café can make a big difference. You’ll have to get a premium subscription to start communicating with other members on Christian Mingle, while Christian Café allows that for free. However, Christian Mingle has more active members and a better user experience, so it might be worth the money.

Winner – Christian Café

Christian Café Pricing

Help & Support

With such a massive user base and a well-designed website, it’s clear that the Christian Mingle vs. Christian Café can have only one winner. Christian Mingle is the dominant part of this category, with active customer support. You can contact them via multiple channels, including email, live chat, and phone. 

Christian Café, on the other hand, only communicates with members via email. That might not be such a big issue if the responses were on time and on topic.

Winner – Christian Mingle

Verdict

When all things are considered, it’s clear that both sites work great for single Christians looking for true love and possibly marriage. Since there can be only one winner, our vote goes to Christian Mingle, as it proved to have better features, design, and overall usability.